Response to Scoop Wellington chain on plans for the public library

The purpose (in the larger cultural/historical picture) of closing or even demolishing the library (and also building a giant white elephant convention centre) was (is still) to destroy the very concept of a ‘public’ library. Read the rest of this entry »

Response to a Scoop discussion on concert venues

On a related topic, a small-ish indoor concert venue, primarily used by local arts groups (music, etc.), is missing from the current scene.  There are popular spots, such as St Andrews on the Terrace, known for its accoustic, which are too small for this niche.  We could use a public (council supported)  ‘medium-sized’ (300-500?) venue designed accoustically for music events.

Why do we think so much of large venues?  Sell more tickets?

Comment on Scoop article on Wellington’s ‘smart motorway’

The $100m smart motorway – but it’ll all depend on the driving

I think we should see some sort of relationship between the bad driving habits of Wellingtonians (New Zealanders) and the uproar in Island Bay. In Island Bay what we see is a response to the fact that the cycleway challenges, or appears to challenge, the total dominance of the motor car in transport planning; finally something has actually been built, rather than just talk.  In terms of current, local politics, the motor car can be seen as a fundamental ingredient in the psyche of the country.  No future in that, so the future is viewed with suspicion.

Richard Keller


The $100m smart motorway – but it’ll all depend on the driving

June 16, 2016Article, Business, Frontpage, Opinion, Politics3 comments

by PCGM The opening date of Wellington’s smart motorway is just around the corner, so we thought it would be worth taking a look at whether it’s really going to work as expected. Short story: the technology is impressive, but it’s a massive social experiment that may or may not work, given some of the less impressive driving habits of Wellingtonians.

The basic idea of the smart motorway is that it automatically smooths the flow of traffic to suit traffic densities, by dynamically altering the speed limit based on how much congestion there is. The intention is that travel times become more predictable, speeds are more consistent because there’s less stop/start queueing, and there are savings in time, stress, CO2, fuel, money … everything up to and including peace in Syria, if the pundits are to be believed.

The basis of the idea lies in the queueing theory – which in this case is the study of how to get all those vehicles to where they’re going as efficiently as possible. And that’s going to be quite important in the years ahead, given that the completion of Transmission Gully will see many more cars dumped at Wellington’s doorstep each morning as people trade the train for the car. So sorting out the backlog and funnelling the cars through the congestion point where SH1 and SH2 arrive in the city will be critical.

The NZ Transport Agency describes how the smart motorway works like this:

Smart motorways reduce congestion by carefully controlling the flow of vehicles. The most critical time when the system can influence the severity of congestion is as the traffic volume begins to build, ie before the road becomes congested. Detectors under the road and radars mounted on lighting poles and gantries count the number of vehicles in each lane, as well as the speed they’re travelling. The smart system calculates the rate at which the road is getting congested, factors in what’s likely to happen based on traffic records that are continually updated and monitored, and automatically adjusts the speed limit to pace the traffic and delay queues being formed.

And NZTA have certainly thrown the kitchen sink of technology at the project. There’s oodles of sensors, piles of computers, an entire stack of algorithms and even a flash new asphalt surface to reduce noise and spray. These guys look like they’re trying really hard to make this thing work – to the tune of chucking more than $100 million at the project.

Of course, it’s still just a road – so how well it works will depend on driver behaviour as much as bleeding-edge technology. And NZTA says that there two things that drivers need to do in order for the smart motorway to work as intended:

– Stick to the posted speed limit (the posted limit is the legal limit) – the smart system calculates the optimum speed to minimise congestion and to get the maximum number of vehicles through the area. As well as breaking the law, exceeding the speed limit will just get drivers to the back of the queue faster and just increase the size and duration of the queue. – Minimise lane changes – changing lanes can have a shockwave effect on following vehicles. If everyone stays in the lane where possible, traffic moves smoothly and everyone gets where they’re going sooner.

And there’s the two problems right there. For starters, NZTA is asking people to actually stick to the speed limit, which will vary based on the time of the day, the amount of traffic, the phase of the moon and a whole bunch of other factors that may be totally invisible to the person behind the wheel. To put it mildly, Wellingtonians aren’t very good at sticking to the speed limit even when it doesn’t change.

Here’s an experiment you can try in order to prove the point. There are roadworks through a big part of the smart motorway section on SH1/2, they’ve been there for ages, and there are 70km/hr signs all up and down the stretch of road. So try setting cruise control to 70km/hr or thereabouts in the middle lane … and watch the traffic zoom past you on both sides, as the bloke behind relentlessly tailgates to try and get you to speed up.

I tried it a few days ago and was passed by practically everything on the road – including a brace of taxis, more courier vans than I could count, a handful of trucks and a bus. All these people are supposed to be professional drivers, yet they looked more like professional scoff-laws. And that’s when the speed limit is fixed, and is in place for the safety of the people in the fluoro vests on the side of the road.

Of course, when you actually stick to the speed limit, NZTA’s other smart motorway rule – don’t randomly change lanes – flies out the window as well. The most entertaining was the courier van who was executing a huge multi-lane weave through traffic like a latter-day Ayrton Senna, before finally dashing across the separator between SH2 and SH1 as he responded to the magnetic pull of the Ngauranga Gorge. I won’t say who the courier company was, but will note that the van was yellow – presumably so the rest of the world could see him coming and prepare themselves for the impact.

The fact is that Kiwis are rubbish drivers. We’re routinely in the lower ranks of the developed nations when it comes to road fatalities, the crash reports are filled with examples of the most appalling judgement, and the road toll is on the rise. So expecting Wellingtonians to drop their normal driving habits – I’ll drive at the speed that suits me because the road ahead doesn’t have much traffic on it – seems like a big ask.

The smart motorway is like NZTA asking drivers to stop texting, cease applying their lippy, look up from the end of their bonnet and start driving with their brains rather than their egos, so everyone gets to work a bit faster. It will be fascinating to see if Wellington responds.


Greens new co-leader less scary?

The Editor, The Wellingtonian,

15 June, 2015

Dear Editor;

The problem with Gordon Campbell’s observation (Wellingtonian, 4 June) that some pundits say voters might be less reluctant to vote Green with James Shaw as co-leader is that it rests on the notion that the electorate looks on the Greens as a bit flaky or worse.   Read the rest of this entry »